DISQUS

Obi · 2 years ago

You're not over-reacting.

Then again, I have seen similar portrayals, of such characters, by South East Asian/Oriental actors; as comedy pieces.

Would help matters more if there were stronger characterisations rather than just the stereotypes.

Phil C. · 2 years ago

Thanks, John, for writing about my piece and including the link to the articles. Keep up the good work. I feel the same way about this movie, an otherwise great film ruined by one thing.

Ernie · 2 years ago

Somehow I thought Long Duk Dong from Sixteen Candles would be #1 until I realized that Gedde Watanabe was the actor. Can an Asian person still make the list? Because I would really, really like it to be.

Simon Bao · 2 years ago

I'm hesitant about the inclusion of Linda Hunt on that list, for her performance in The Year of Living Dangerously. I mean, on reflection, it is more odd that the non-Asian Linda Hunt was cast as a Eurasian (Australian/Chinese)? Or, that the female actor Linda Hunt was cast as the male photographer Billy Kwan?

In any case, her selection for that role doesn't seem even remotely infamous to me. Her performance was exceptional, dignified, humane in every respect. Would it have been realistic to put Linda Hunt aside and hold out hopes that a Eurasian male dwarf was going to audition for the role and be good enough to win the Oscar that year?

Did I miss something, or did the list not include all the Caucasian actors cast as Ming the Merciless. Emperor Ming, The Mother of All Asian Supervillains. Ruler of all Mongo, a Stereotypes on Steroids. :-)

John · 2 years ago

Phil C. - oh, wow - cool that the author of the article reads 8asians.com and contacts me - that's a first for me. Thanks for your kind words and interesting article.

Phil C. · 2 years ago

John -- you and all the other bloggers here are doing a great job. Keep it up.

Gerald · 2 years ago

Well, I don't see why anybody would be shocked. Hollywood still believes that all Asians can be lumped together into one big "o-ree-yental" group and cast as each other. I mean, it's only very, very recently (like Last Samurai recently) that I've seen movies with major Japanese parts that weren't played by a Chinese actor. It's a slow process. The fact that Rooney's performance is so out of place points to the possibility that he was stuck in there at the behest of some backwoods special interest group at the last minute. Disgusting. Yes. But probably progressive for the time in that at least Yoniushi wasn't a drug dealer or white slaver on the side, like the "Asian" character in Thoroughly Modern Minnie.

Nelson · 1 year ago

You are not overreacting - Mickey Rooney's act was one of the most egregious examples I have ever seen. I also add Ricardo Montalban in Sayonara and Rex Harrison as the King of Siam. Ricardo Montalban was not trying to be overtly insulting but the whole attempt looked foolish.